2017
Megan Rea (Jackson) - University of Mount Union
Sydney Dickerson (Glenoak) - Cleary University
Lisa Dickerson (Glenoak) - Cleary University
2018
Sammie Battista (Hoover) - University of Mount Union
Katie Hibinger (Wadsworth) - Indiana University of Pennsylvania
2019
Kelsey Burns (Medina) - Marietta College
Aurora Frazier (CVCA) - Hiram College
Emily Jewell (Wooster) - Ashland University
Tori Sharlow (Louisville) - Ashland University
2020
Emma Pascu (Lake) - Capital University
Avary Snyder (Lake) - Ohio Northern University
Katie Mendenhall (North Canton) - Walsh University
Brianna Doctor (Stow) - Ursuline College
Isabella Robatin (Brecksville) - University of Mount Union
2021
Kennedy Norch (Jackson) - Muskingum University
Keaghan Burden (Brunswick) - Ohio Northern University
Camryn English (Louisville) - Muskingum University
Erin Snyder (Lake Catholic HS) - Lake Erie College
Zoe Chamberlin (Wooster) - Baldwin Wallace
Abigail May (St Vincent-St Mary) - Marietta College
Victoria Leonard (Jackson) - North Central College
2022
Liandra Watson (Glenoak) - Georgetown College